Silky Smooth Raptor Bay
Raptor Bay, near Naples, begins with an interesting idea: there will be no bunkers. That’s the most notable thing about the course — and also its biggest flaw. Even that premise isn’t completely fulfilled. In lieu of formal bunkers are large sandy beaches running alongside fairways and greens, so there’s still sand, even if you’re allowed to drive and ground your club in it.
The setting is rare for this market with the holes cut out of deep woods on the border of Estero Bay and no surrounding development to speak of. In southwest Florida you have to go to extreme upscale private clubs (Calusa Pines) to buy this kind of isolation, even though a few condo towers are visible around the perimeter.
The slick, wall-to-wall fairways and low to the ground green settings are a nice touch, though even it’s done with more energy at Greg Norman’s Tiburón 30 minutes south. There are some solid golf holes, including the five par-3’s that manage to remain interesting in spite of the lack of topography, and the architecture presents a good mix of green shapes and orientations so pin positions play a meaningful role in how the holes should be approached.
But ultimately this is a lesson in the importance of good bunkering and how creating different lines of play is vital to diversity and presenting consequence. Without formal bunkers the holes feels neutered and repetitive. Flat, listless sites like this are incapable of fully engaging without thought provoking hazards beyond common water features. In its attempt to be original, Raptor Bay becomes forgettable. (85)
Estero/Naples
Architect: Raymond Floyd
Year: 2001